Update to the “Carnivorous Wild Horses” article

Cannibalistic horses...Really??

As pointed out in the article below – the anti-horse crowd in Australia are getting desperate. Attempting to use “scientists” to rationalize horse culling (and thus slaughter) by saying these horses are eating other horses is a disgusting ruse. These horses were NOT eating other horses. ~ HfH

From: The Sydney Morning Herald
By: John Thistleton

Cannibalistic horses...Really??

Cannibalistic horses…Really?? Of course not!

ANU academics who wrote about three starving horses eating the innards of a dead horse last month should have called for help for the animals and not exploited them for a sensationalist story, say Snowy Mountains horse riders.

Dr Don Driscoll and Dr Sam Banks’ claims were made to underline their case for a resumption of aerial culling in the mountains. They reckon between 7000 and 11000 horses will die from starvation, poisoning or dehydration over a decade if aerial culling is not included in management plans.

The horse riders association’s spokeswoman Leisa Caldwell said the academics were irresponsible. Ms Caldwell also criticised Kosciuszko National Park managers for not allowing her members to remove the horses.

“You don’t need a university degree to know that horses are not carnivorous but were probably nibbling at their fallen mates’ caecum and intestines for the undigested herbaceous matter to survive,” Ms Caldwell said.

“The sickening part of this story is that our horsemen requested on two occasions to go and remove those horses before winter set in but were not permitted to do so by park managers. These horses should have been saved and re-homed,” Ms Caldwell said in a statement.

The researchers’ claims also provoked stinging criticism from Snowy Mountains Bush Users Group president Peter Cochran. Mr Cochran said his members had been aware of the horses and were in contact with NSW National Parks staff about them.

A spokeswoman for National Parks said staff attended horses at two locations in the southern part of the park: Cootapatamba Hut and Dead Horse Gap.

At Cootapatamba Hut, a lone horse was euthanased on humane grounds after discussions with the RSPCA and Mr Cochran.

“At Dead Horse Gap, about six kilometres south of Thredbo, there were five snowbound horses, three alive and two dead. NPWS staff monitored the three surviving horses, which were in very poor condition, and considered euthanasia on humane grounds, however mustered them to lighter snow cover and they are believed to have survived,” the spokeswoman said.

Ms Caldwell said the two researchers’ story and video, ‘The grim story of the Snowy Mountains’ cannibal horses’ made staggering claims of brumbies turning to cannibalism.

“Many SMHRA members are descendants of the original Snowy Mountains pioneers and their families have managed the brumbies for more than 150 years. They are appalled at the outrageous comments by the ANU visitors who spent two days in the mountains recently,” she said.

Ms Caldwell said a National Parks draft of the official count taken in May, 2014, had said numbers could be as low as 3800 brumbies in the whole of Kosciusko National Park.

“It is becoming clear that some ANU academics and their anti-horse lobby friends are getting quite desperate and are going to any lengths to see our brumbies exterminated,” Ms Caldwell said.

Continue Reading

  • Louie C

    “They” certainly are getting desperate.
    THE CONVERSATION deleted 4 of my comments and then closed comments altogether.
    This publication does not encourage an open format or public discussion.

    September 25, 2014
  • Louie C

    Great Britain is part of the European Union and this all ties in with those international trade agreements and the global market. That’s could be one reason that Princess Anne suddenly came out in favor of Horse slaughter?

    Horses and other equidae are considered by law to be food-producing species in the European Union

    September 25, 2014
  • arlene

    This Story is the weakest attempt to castize Wild Mustangs and the scientific years spent reserching evidence made to prove the fact that Mustangs are not only stunningly beautiful , enviormentally , ecologically the most needed species ever to grace this EARTH< with their presence !!!! These people need some extensive mental evaluations, and should spent their time getting help, instead of trying to eliminate the Fabulous Mustangs , the Mustangs througout History have given stunning beauty, joy and also so needed by the enviorment and they also are ecolgically perfect for everyone of us ……and the earth………..even the wind and air call out to them for assistence !!!!!! Get a darn clue MORONS……………………………..

    September 27, 2014
  • arlene

    Ohhh , heres the help these demented morons need , maybe they should beg for a Team of Mustangs to help their demented minds to heal !!!!! Also Mustangs are Physcotheripists, and very forgiving !!!!!! They will never deny their services !!!!!or charge for them either…………………

    September 27, 2014