How to kill 100 horses and get a slap on the wrist


Bismarck Tribune, August 2, 2013, Jenny Michael

(The news on the sentencing on this major case of neglect and starvation came out over 6 weeks ago. Having been involved in these cases before, I know what kind of psychological effect it has on the responders, The damage is made far worse when the bad guys walk away.  Causing even a single equine to die of starvation should be a felony. There is no acceptable excuse that can be given for such acts.

In North Dakota the world must be perceived differently, for killing horses by starvation is little worse than driving with an expired driver’s license. Killing 100 horses in Bismarck translates to 120 days of electronic monitoring and a fine of $1500. Why even bother? Perhaps they should just sentence him to work for Rick De Los Santos.—- Jerry)

The beginnings of this case can be found HERE

The rescued that stepped in to pick up the pieces – HERE

0313 102 Horses Starved Photo 2BISMARCK, N.D. — William Kiefer has pleaded guilty to nine animal abuse charges for the deaths of more than 100 horses and the starvation of others.

Kiefer did not appear in court Friday to plead guilty to the charges, but his attorney, Charles Stock, entered the pleas to the nine counts of Class A misdemeanor overworking, mistreating or abandoning animals. Defendants in misdemeanor cases do not have to appear in court if they designate that their attorneys are appearing for them. Kiefer has not appeared at any of the hearings in the case or related civil cases involving the surviving animals.

South Central District Judge Tom Schneider ordered a presentence investigation be conducted. Each charge carries a maximum sentence of one year in jail. Attorneys in the case have recommended sentences that would put Kiefer in jail or on electronic monitoring for 120 days and on supervised probation for two years. He also would have to pay $1,500 in fines to animal rescue operations.

In late January, officials in Morton and Burleigh counties seized more than 150 horses and mules from properties owned by Kiefer after finding 96 dead animals on property northwest of New Salem and three dead on pasture east of Bismarck. Several other animals later died. Kiefer is accused in both the Burleigh County and Morton County cases of failing to provide necessary food, water and shelter to his animals.

According to a complaint in the Morton County case, one count of overworking, mistreating or abandoning animals is in response to a group of horses and mules found dead on a hilltop in the pasture northwest of New Salem, another count is for animals found dead in a barn and a third count is for dead animals in a Quonset and nearby trailer. A fourth count is for animals found dead in a hay yard, while the fifth count is for all the surviving animals.

Three of the charges in Burleigh County are for animals found dead on Kiefer’s property, and the fourth charge is for the surviving animals.

Sweetie Pie, pictured in the photo at left, was one of the horses that did not make it.

Sweetie Pie, pictured in the photo at left, was one of the horses that did not make it.

Prosecutors and Stock recommended Kiefer be sentenced to one year in jail on all of the charges, with all but 120 days suspended, two years of supervised probation and court fees. Burleigh County Assistant State’s Attorney Justin Schwartz and Morton County Assistant State’s Attorney Gabrielle Goter recommended Kiefer pay a $750 fine in each county to either a humane society or Triple H Miniature Horse Rescue, which took in many of the horses in the case and helped get them adopted.

Under the recommendations, Kiefer would be able to serve the sentence under electronic monitoring rather than in a jail.

The attorneys said the recommendation was appropriate because it took into consideration how serious the case was and the fact that Kiefer has no prior criminal history. Schwartz said a typical first offense for such a case would be resolved with a deferred or suspended sentence. —CONTINUED

AUTHOR: Jerry Finch
  • Jan Schultz

    Before sentencing, the court should have watched all videos with sound of all thje sights the rescuers saw. I think I remember your blogs at the time and my heart broke for the suffering of the animals. Surely, a child watching those tapes would be forever horrified if knowing a human had caused such a thing. That is why we have animal cruelty laws – to protect each other from suffering angst or pain at the sight of the breaking of the peace in such a way. The laws are to ensure peaceful coexistence. When the judges get their heads out of their butts and see the damage done by the news and record of what this man did – maybe they will realize the proper prospective. How do you excuse the deliberate infliction of callous torture? The words just fail me.

    September 18, 2013
  • N.Laurel

    On the “continued” segment;” Kiefer has a “deep affinity for equine animals” but let the situation on his Burleigh and Morton county properties get out of control. Kiefer is ashamed and feels badly for the animals, Stock said. He said Kiefer is a “good, decent man.”. What criteria makes a “decent man”?
    To me, Kiefer is not even human. As this World’s justice system won’t seek justice for those equines, then it will have to be doled out in the next World’s system.

    September 18, 2013

    My answer now to all animal abusers is I HOPE THEY DIE IN JAIL AND GO TO HELL. So in this case, I only have 120 days for the first to come true, but I know that he will go to hell.

    September 18, 2013
  • mary Gardner

    So sad!!

    September 18, 2013
  • Sue

    Obviously, the laws of every state MUST change. The Animal Legal Defense Fund works on such legislative changes. They have overturned a couple of ag gag laws, for example. Visit to see their work.

    September 18, 2013
  • Nancy Albin

    Misdameaner!!!!!!! You have got to be kidding!!! I sure hope the Judical system & Hopefully the New President see things for what they are & note that if we ran Americas legal system like they do in other countries then maybe these kind of “abuse crimes” won’t exist anymore they already found that “Hillary Clintons” laws of keeping the child with the immidiate parent no matter what kind of abusive parent they are as long as they have money will keep crime rates down didn’t work all that has done is make the child go through abuse! I know I went through this! so I see not only BLM being a government dept. oh … this makes me sick!!!! I’m sorry Jerry for the things i say on your web i don’t mean to disrespect you, but i am having a real hard time swallowing what is happening to our voicless in America I m litterally getting fed up!! & the sad thing of it all is I have 2 young daughters alone in this world of evil!

    September 18, 2013
  • Nina

    Things have GOT to change with our judicial systems. Having animal cruelty laws in place is fine and dandy but when they are never enforced….what are you supposed to do?? I currently work with a horse rescue and we have pictures – COLOR PICTURES – documenting the abuse, yet the judge STILL will not act! I don’t get it….I just don’t get it. We cannot fight the abusers and law enforcement too. We will never win.

    September 18, 2013