Estrogens Derived From Horse Urine Linked to Heart Disease Risk
A new study that finds higher risks of deep vein thrombosis blood clots in those taking conjugated estrogens for menopause symptoms.
From: Everydayhealth.com By: Jennifer J Brown, PhD
MONDAY, September 30, 2013 — The cardiovascular risk of using estrogen therapy to reduce women’s menopause symptoms like hot flashes and vaginal dryness has often been hotly debated. Adding fuel to the fire is a new study that links conjugated equine estrogen hormone therapy — estrogen derived from the urine of pregnant horses — to a woman’s risk of developing heart disease.
Nicholas L Smith, PhD, an epidemiologist from the University of Washington School of Public Health, and other researchers studied the heart health of 384 women who were postmenopausal and taking hormone replacement therapy, HRT. The women were ages 30 to 79, and members of a health maintenance organization in Washington, the Group Health Cooperative.
The investigators found a total of 68 cases of women with deep vein thrombosis — blood clots — and 67 of heart attack, along with another 48 cases of stroke. Which estrogen medications the women had taken were studied, in order to uncover any links to heart disease risk.
Women who used the estrogens that came from horse urine — also know as Premarin — were twice as likely to have venous thrombosis. The women taking conjugated equine estrogen were also slightly more likely to have heart attacks, but risk of stroke did not vary based on which medication was taken.
“Now with this new information we are learning to choose wisely. It seems that different preparations of HRT carry unique risk,” said Stephanie Moore, MD, a cardiologist at the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Institute for Heart, Vascular and Stroke Care’s Heart Failure and Cardiac Transplant Program in Boston. Dr. Moore was not involved with the study.
How Estrogens Affect Heart Health Risks
Taking the analysis a step further, the study investigators compared blood samples from the women by looking at blood factors that lead to clotting. They discovered significantly higher levels of clotting factors in women who took the horse-derived estrogens. This finding provides biochemical evidence for the cardiovascular risk the women experienced, and that may have led to the blood clotting of venous thrombosis.
“When we first started studying the effects of hormone replacement on women’s cardiovascular health,” Dr. Moore said, “the initial thought was that all hormone replacement strategies led to increased heart attack and stroke for all women.” Follow-up studies contested the risks to women’s heart health.
“Over years of follow-up we have learned to individualize treatment and that HRT (hormone replacement therapy) is not necessarily bad for all women,” said Moore. “Actually, it is a small minority that has increased risk of heart attack or stroke with HRT. The majority of women are safe,” she emphasized.
The study authors concluded that more comparative safety investigations like this are needed. They wrote that if their results were confirmed, “The number of avoidable venous and possibly cardiac thrombotic events may be lowered by selecting lower-risk medications.”
Habitat for Horses is a 501.c.3 nonprofit equine protection organization supported solely by donations. We have around 200 donkeys and horses under our care, plus one ornery, old mule. Most of them are here because law enforcement removed them from their previous owner. Our ability to rehabilitate and rehome them comes from the financial support of people like you. Please support us by making a donation for the horses we all serve. Click HERE to donate